Property Damage & Insurance

Contested Insurance Claim — Newport Beach Commercial Property

Overview

A multi-tenant commercial property in Newport Beach suffered extensive water damage following a major roof failure during a severe storm. The carrier's initial adjuster provided a repair estimate of $450,000, claiming the majority of the damage was pre-existing and cosmetic. The owner was left with a facility that could not be fully operational, facing over $1.2M in contractor estimates for necessary structural repairs and mold remediation.

The Challenge

The carrier's estimate relied on standardized pricing software that failed to account for the complexities of commercial construction in coastal Orange County. Furthermore, the carrier's scope omitted significant structural repairs required by local building codes and attempted to classify sudden water damage as long-term deterioration.

MC Consulting's Approach

MC Consulting was retained to perform an independent Bid Document Review (BDR).
We conducted an exhaustive forensic site inspection, identifying hidden structural damage missed by the initial adjuster.
We developed a comprehensive, 150-page line-item repair scope based on actual local market pricing, not generic software averages.
We compiled a defensible report detailing the necessary code upgrades required for compliance and actively participated in negotiations with the carrier's adjusters.

Project Details

Service Category

Property Damage & Insurance

Location

Newport Beach, CA

Timeline

Fall 2024

Client

Commercial Property Owner

Key Metrics

$450,000

Initial Offer

$1.35M

Final Settlement

200%

Increase Secured

“Matt’s analysis was the turning point in our insurance dispute. His documentation was thorough, professional, and undeniable. He spoke the language the adjusters needed to hear.”

Robert T.

Property Owner

The Outcome

Armed with our detailed and authoritative BDR, the property owner’s legal team successfully challenged the carrier’s initial offer. The final settlement was increased to $1.35M (a 200% increase), allowing the owner to complete the necessary repairs without suffering a massive out-of-pocket loss.

Need similar results?

Related Services

Property Damage & Insurance

Learn more

Ready to Protect Your Investment?

Get a free consultation with Southern California’s trusted construction consulting experts.